In analysis of an argument question you must either agree or disagree with the author's argument, supporting your argument logically and structuring the essay effectively.
At least once during the course of writing your essay, isolate what you consider to be your thesis. Is your proposition both arguable and reasonable? If it is obvious (i.e. Mary Rowlandson used the Bible for comfort during her captivity) you don’t have an argument. Argument requires analysis (i.e. taking things apart and explaining them). One test that may help is asking yourself what the opposite "side" of your argument would be. A good, complicated thesis (which was proposed by one of your classmates) is that "Although Mary Rowlandson says she often used the Bible as a source of comfort during her captivity, a closer reading of her narrative suggests her faith may have been more troubled by her experience than she lets on." One useful structure for writing thesis statements is the "although" form used above: "Although x seems to be true about this piece of literature, y is in fact more true (or makes our thinking about x more complex)." In this form you present both sides of your argument at once and show which side you’re on. Your job in the paper is to convince your reader to join you. Another way to write an effective thesis statement is to use the form "If we look closely at x (e.g. how Bradford defines freedom) we discover y (that ).
For example: while a persuasive paper might claim that cities need to adopt recycling programs, an argument paper on the same topic might be addressed to a particular town. The argument paper would go further, suggesting specific ways that a recycling program should be adopted and utilized in that particular area.
The ideal analysis essay uses:
1) Clear, correct sentences (and whenever possible, varied sentence length and structure)
2) An introduction in which you announce the author and essay you’ve chosen and ends with a thesis statement
3) A brief summary of the author’s topic and argument
4) A subtopic like device (tone, structure, etc.) rather than stepping through the author’s piece linearly
5) Body paragraphs that develop your thesis statement and demonstrate both unity and coherence in their analytical, close reading
6) A conclusion that communicates your thesis in a new way and emphasizes the importance of your topic to the reader. Leave the reader with something for further thought
Argument essay template, if anyone wants it
You have to be a critical reader—another term is close reader—to write an argument analysis. Your goal is to go beyond the obvious. You want your readers to feel significantly taught as a result of reading your essay. Also remember that you are not writing a summary. You’re analyzing the ways in which a writer effectively makes her/his point. You are also not writing a critique. Your job in this essay is to create an argument that examines the author’s purpose/goals and methods. In other words, what exactly is the author saying, and how is s/he getting that idea across?
GMAT Argument Essay : Analysis of an argument
The sample argument that the stars are gods has an unstated premise, namely:
"Whatever helps us tell time accurately is beneficial." (In this case the fact that the premise is unstated is relatively harmless.)6. Sometimes, words or sentences within a passage of text that contains anargument will play no logical role at all. You can set those aside when youanalyze an argument.
"Hear me now and believe me later" in the prose argument does nological work at all. The phrase "What's more" is useful for indicating a new setof reasons in support of the ultimate conclusion, but it serves more as agrammatical divider than as a logical indicator.
2) The argumentative essay has three approaches. Choose the one that you find most effective for your argument. Do you find it better to “sell” your argument first and then present the counter arguments and refute them? Or do you prefer to save the best for last?
How to Write a Comparative Essay (with Pictures) - wikiHow
Tips for writing argumentative essays:
1) Make a list of the pros and cons in your plan before you start writing. Choose the most important that support your argument (the pros) and the most important to refute (the cons) and focus on them.